Bonuses sound simple.
Your team hits a target. You pay them more.
The problem is that a bonus can easily become expensive without actually making your practice better.
Dr. Blake Hamblin has learned this the hard way.
He has built bonus structures that worked for a while, only to realize later that they were rewarding the wrong thing or creating a long-term expense he did not intend to create. The bigger lesson was not to stop using bonuses. It was to change what the bonus was designed to accomplish.
Instead of asking:
“How do I pay my team more when revenue goes up?”
Blake started asking:
“How do I use money to grow people?”
That shift changes everything.
A good bonus should not simply reward someone for doing the job they were already hired to do.
It should help you develop a person, transfer knowledge, create another layer of leadership, or move the practice toward a measurable goal.
And you do not always need a permanent bonus to do it.
Sometimes the smartest bonus is a one-time payment that gets someone from Point A to Point B.
“How do we switch it from revenue to growing people?”
Stop Thinking About Bonuses as Extra Pay
The first mistake is treating a bonus like a second paycheck.
Someone does their job well, so you give them extra money.
Then they keep doing their job well, so you keep paying the bonus.
Eventually, the bonus becomes something everyone expects.
Now you have a permanent expense attached to a behavior that may not be creating anything new.
Blake’s approach is different.
If someone is already doing their job, the question becomes:
What could this person do next?
Maybe they can train another employee.
Maybe they can improve a department metric.
Maybe they can teach another hygienist.
Maybe they can mentor an associate.
Maybe they can help build a process that makes the whole team better.
That is where the bonus becomes useful.
You are not paying someone to answer the phone.
You are paying them to teach someone else how to answer the phone well.
You are not paying a hygienist to do their normal job.
You are paying them to help another hygienist reach the same performance level.
You are not simply giving a high-producing doctor a raise.
You might use their expertise to help other doctors improve.
The goal is to create more capability inside the practice.
And when people become better at what they do, revenue can follow.
Watch: Why Your Current Bonus System Is Failing (And How to Fix It Fast)
The Best Bonus May Be a One-Time Bonus
This is one of the most useful distinctions from Blake’s approach.
There is a difference between a development bonus and a recurring performance bonus.
A recurring bonus can make sense when you have a durable system tied to ongoing performance.
A one-time bonus can be better when you are trying to solve a temporary problem.
For example:
You hire a new treatment coordinator.
They need to learn the role.
You have an experienced treatment coordinator who already knows the job.
Instead of immediately changing the experienced person’s role or giving them permanent additional compensation, create a specific challenge.
“If in the next 30 days you can take Jane and build Jane to be 80% of where you’re at, I’m going to pay you a $500 bonus.”
Now the experienced employee has a clear target.
The new employee gets better faster.
The practice transfers knowledge.
And the experienced employee gets rewarded for creating another capable person.
That is a much different outcome than simply adding $500 to someone’s paycheck every month.
The Real Goal: Grow People
This is the philosophy underneath the entire system.
Grow people and the practice gets stronger.
When Blake changed his thinking from growing revenue to growing people, he found that revenue could follow because better people tend to perform better, develop others, and improve the organization around them.
That gives you a much better question when designing incentives:
What capability do I want to create?
Not:
What number do I want to hit?
But:
- Who needs to become better?
- What skill needs to transfer?
- Who can teach it?
- What measurable outcome proves it worked?
- What should happen after they reach the target?
That is incentive design.
Read: When Growth Creates Chaos: The Systems Every Dental Practice Needs to Scale
Use Your Best People to Develop Your Next Best People
Gary pointed out a common mistake in dental practices.
Someone is excellent at their current job, so the owner promotes them into leadership.
Now the practice loses one of its best performers from the original position.
The new leader may not know how to manage.
Nobody has trained them.
And nobody has replaced the work they were previously doing.
You have created two problems instead of solving one.
A development bonus gives you another option.
Keep the person in their lane.
Then give them a temporary assignment:
Teach someone else what you know.
That lets you test something important.
Can this person actually grow other people?
Blake described it as a way to discover whether someone has the skill to ascend within the organization or whether they simply prefer to be excellent in their current role.
Both outcomes are useful.
If they love teaching and are good at it, you may have found your next leader.
If they would rather stay in their current role, that’s okay too.
Not everyone wants to manage people.
You should not assume that everyone who is excellent at their job wants a leadership position.
Read: Want to Grow? Fix Your Hiring First
“If you can grow people, you can have this money.”
Give People a Test Before You Give Them a New Title
This may be the simplest way to avoid bad promotions.
Do not immediately say:
“You’re great at this. Now you’re the leader.”
Instead, give them a small leadership experiment.
For example:
Challenge: Train a new front desk employee.
Time: 30 days.
Target: New employee reaches 80% of the trainer’s defined performance level.
Reward: $500 bonus.
Documentation: Create or improve the training process along the way.
Now you get to observe the person.
Do they enjoy teaching?
Can they communicate?
Can they break a process down?
Can they be patient?
Can they create a repeatable system?
Do they actually want more responsibility?
You have learned a lot without permanently changing their job.
Gary also pointed out that this can uncover hidden skills. If someone trains one person quickly and effectively, you can give them another challenge and see whether they can repeat the result.
That is how you find future leaders.
Read: The Two Leadership Rules That Transformed a 20-Patient Practice Into a 200-Patient Powerhouse
Build Growth Tracks Without Forcing Management
One of the biggest problems in dental practices is that there is often nowhere for a great employee to go.
A hygienist becomes a great hygienist.
Then what?
An assistant becomes an excellent assistant.
Then what?
A front desk employee becomes outstanding.
Then what?
The answer does not always need to be management.
Some people want stability.
Some people want to become better at their current job.
Some people want more responsibility.
Some want leadership.
The incentive system can help you discover which path fits.
Gary described how one-time bonuses can create additional opportunities without forcing someone into a completely different position. A strong employee can help another person improve, earn an additional reward, and still remain excellent at their primary role.
That creates more ways for people to grow.
And people can feel like they have a future inside the practice.
Bonus Design Rule
A bonus should have a job. Before offering money, identify the exact behavior or capability you want to create. Training another employee, improving a measurable KPI, documenting a process, or mentoring another doctor gives the bonus a purpose. “Do a better job” is too vague. Define the result, the deadline, and the reward before you launch it.
Example: Developing a Front Desk Employee
Let’s say your front desk has been struggling.
You bring in someone new.
Do not immediately overwhelm them with everything they need to know.
Blake’s approach is to establish a small foundation first.
Tell the new employee:
“By the end of this week, I want you to understand these three things.”
Then define exactly what those three things are.
A, B, and C.
That’s the win for the week.
Once the employee understands the position, you can identify a specific performance problem and build an incentive around it.
For example:
Your missed-call rate is 40%.
Your goal is 20%.
You could create a one-time $500 bonus if the team reduces the missed-call rate by the agreed target during the defined period.
Now the bonus has a purpose.
It is not:
“Do your job better.”
It is:
“Let’s solve this measurable problem.”
And Blake’s approach also leaves room for the employee to find a better solution.
If they discover that technology could solve part of the missed-call problem, that is valuable information too. The employee is starting to think like a business partner rather than simply waiting for instructions.
Example: Use Your Best Hygienist to Train the Next Hygienist
The same model works clinically.
Suppose you hire a new hygienist.
You already have someone who performs extremely well.
Instead of pulling the experienced hygienist into management, give them a specific development assignment.
Tell them:
“Show the new hygienist how you do it.”
Then define the metrics.
Blake mentioned examples such as hygiene reappointment rate, fluoride, lasers, and microscope-related performance. If the new hygienist reaches the agreed targets on several of those metrics, the experienced hygienist earns a one-time bonus.
The important part is the measurement.
Do not say:
“Train them well.”
Say:
“Get them to this level on these three metrics.”
Now everyone knows what success looks like.
The Same Idea Works With Doctors
The framework does not stop with support staff.
Blake shared an example of a high-performing associate who wanted a raise.
Instead of simply increasing the associate’s pay for their own production, the owner could use that doctor’s strength to improve the rest of the doctors.
If three other doctors are producing at different levels, the high performer can coach them and receive additional compensation tied to the improvement they create.
Now the practice is paying for leverage, not simply individual production.
That creates a very different growth path for a high performer.
Instead of:
“You’re producing more, so here’s more money.”
You can eventually get to:
“You’re producing at a high level. Now show us how to make other people better.”
If they can do that, you may have discovered someone who can help you scale.
“The best way to learn something is to teach it.”
Every Bonus Should Start as a Beta
This is one of Gary’s strongest practical recommendations.
Treat every new bonus structure as an experiment.
Give it a defined test period.
Gary suggested 30 to 90 days.
Then review it.
You may keep it.
You may change it.
You may remove it.
You may discover that the target was wrong.
You may discover that the reward was too large.
You may discover that the team responds differently than you expected.
That is exactly why you should not assume the first version is permanent.
Before launching a new bonus, define:
- The problem
- The behavior you want
- The measurable target
- The time period
- The reward
- How success will be reviewed
Then tell your team:
“We’re testing this.”
That creates flexibility.
It also prevents you from accidentally locking yourself into a bonus structure that becomes expensive or difficult to change.
Beta First
Treat a new bonus structure as a test. Set a 30-to-90-day window, explain that the system may change, and review the results afterward. This gives you room to adjust the target, reward, or measurement before a temporary idea turns into a permanent expense.
Stop Making Bonuses All-or-Nothing
Blake also identified another problem with bonus design.
You hit the target or you do not.
That creates unnecessary tension.
Imagine a treatment coordinator has a $1,000 monthly bonus.
The target is 30% treatment acceptance and 70% patient acceptance.
They finish at 29.8% and 69.8%.
Now what?
Do you pay the bonus because they were close?
Do you refuse and disappoint them?
Either way, the structure creates a problem.
Blake suggested using bands of incentives instead.
For example:
| Performance | Bonus Payout |
| Baseline target | 75% |
| Higher target | 100% |
| Stretch target | 125% |
The exact numbers should depend on your practice.
The important idea is creating levels.
Now the team has something to chase instead of one giant cliff.
Give High Performers Another Level to Reach
A bonus system can also evolve.
If someone consistently hits the highest tier, you have learned something.
The incentive is no longer stretching them.
That does not necessarily mean you should keep increasing their base pay every time.
Gary described a situation where a high performer consistently reached the top of the existing bonus system. Instead of simply continuing to pay the same bonus indefinitely, the company created a higher tier and gave the employee another target.
That creates another level of growth.
There is also an interesting twist:
Let the high performer help create the next target.
Gary noted that when high performers participate in setting their next goal, they can be more invested in reaching it because they helped create it.
That is very different from an owner simply dropping a new number on someone’s desk.
Leadership Test
Don’t automatically promote your best employee just because they are excellent at their current job. Give them a small opportunity to teach someone else first. If they can develop another person, communicate clearly, and enjoy the responsibility, you have learned something about their leadership potential without creating a permanent role change.
Read: How to Handle Dental Team Raise Requests: A Framework That Protects Your Practice and Your Culture
A Simple Bonus Framework for Your Practice
If you are trying to redesign bonuses, start here.
Step 1: Identify the person you want to grow
Who could become better?
Who could teach someone else?
Who could take on a bigger challenge?
Step 2: Identify the capability
Do not start with revenue.
Start with the capability.
Examples:
- Train a new employee
- Improve missed-call rate
- Improve hygiene reappointment
- Improve treatment acceptance
- Mentor another doctor
- Document a process
Step 3: Define the finish line
Make the goal measurable.
Do not say:
“Make them better.”
Say:
“Get them to 80% of your current performance within 30 days.”
Step 4: Choose the reward
Money works.
But Blake also pointed out that freedom can be valuable. A paid day off or additional PTO may motivate certain people more than cash.
Ask what the person actually values.
Step 5: Set a deadline
A bonus without a deadline can become vague.
Give it a start date and an end date.
Step 6: Run it as a beta
Start with 30 to 90 days.
Review the results.
Then decide what happens next.
Step 7: Decide whether the person should ascend
Did they demonstrate leadership?
Did they enjoy teaching?
Did they improve someone else?
Do they want more?
Now you have information to make the next decision.
The Point Isn’t the Bonus
This is the biggest lesson.
The bonus is just the tool.
The actual objective is building a practice where people can get better and help other people get better.
That is what creates leverage.
You have one excellent person.
Instead of moving them out of their role, use them to create another excellent person.
Then another.
Then another.
Eventually, the practice does not depend on one person knowing everything.
Knowledge starts moving through the team.
People start supporting one another.
And leadership becomes something you can develop instead of something you have to hire from outside.
That is a much better reason to use bonuses.
Key Takeaways
- Do not use bonuses simply to pay people more for doing their existing job.
- Use bonuses to grow people, transfer knowledge, and solve specific problems.
- One-time bonuses are useful for short-term development goals.
- Keep great employees in their current roles while testing their ability to train others.
- Define exactly what success looks like before offering the reward.
- Treat new bonus structures as 30-to-90-day experiments.
- Use incentive bands instead of making every bonus all-or-nothing.
- Give high performers a new level to reach once they consistently hit the top tier.
Conclusion
A bonus system should make your practice stronger.
If it simply makes payroll more complicated, you probably need to rethink it.
The best question to ask is not:
“What can I pay someone to get better results?”
Ask:
“Who can I grow?”
Then figure out what skill, behavior, or capability you want that person to develop.
Give them a clear target.
Give them a reason to care.
Give them a defined time frame.
And then see what happens.
You may discover that your best hygienist can train the next hygienist.
Your best front desk employee can build the next front desk employee.
Your best doctor can raise the performance of the doctors around them.
And someone you never considered a leader may show you that they can grow people.
That is when a bonus becomes more than extra money.
It becomes a development tool.
Listen to the Full Episode
In Episode 63 of My Dental Playbook, Dr. Blake Hamblin and Gary Bird break down how to build bonuses that actually develop your team, including one-time training bonuses, performance targets, incentive bands, beta periods, and ways to create new growth opportunities without automatically promoting your best employee.
Listen: The $500 Bonus That Builds Leaders