Dental hygiene gets blamed for a lot of problems in dentistry.
Low profitability. Staffing shortages. Empty chairs. High hygienist pay. Insurance pressure. Scheduling headaches.
But there is another way to look at it.
Hygiene can be one of the biggest growth engines in your practice.
Dr. Blake Hamblin, Andrew Vallo, and Dr. Collin Myrick operate very different dental practices. Blake runs a fee-for-service model in a competitive city. Andrew runs multiple in-network practices with a heavy focus on volume. Collin runs large practices in communities where new patients come largely through demand rather than sophisticated marketing.
Their models are different.
Their lessons about hygiene are surprisingly similar.
The big one is this:
“The name of the game is active patient count. It’s not new patient count.”
If you want hygiene to drive growth, you need to solve three problems:
- Get enough patients into the hygiene schedule.
- Keep those patients coming back.
- Build enough capacity and accountability to handle the demand.
Here is how they are doing it.
Hygiene Does Not Have to Be Your Profit Center
Blake’s first point changes the way you should think about hygiene.
He wants hygiene to be profitable.
But he is completely comfortable with hygiene not being the profit center of the practice.
Why?
Because hygiene can be a gateway into the practice.
If reducing the barrier to a hygiene appointment gets more patients through your doors, the economics do not end with the cleaning.
That patient may:
- Need restorative treatment
- Accept larger treatment later
- Refer friends or family
- Leave a Google review
- Return for future hygiene appointments
- Become part of your active patient base
Blake described this as an abundance mindset. If you can get the patient into the practice, there are many opportunities to create value afterward.
Andrew uses a similar philosophy, especially for new patients.
He describes new-patient hygiene as a loss leader.
His question is not:
“Did I make money on today’s cleaning?”
It is:
“What can this patient be worth to the practice over time?”
That distinction matters.
Andrew’s $98 to $58 experiment
Andrew’s practices had traditionally offered a $98 new-patient special that included X-rays, an exam, a healthy-mouth cleaning, and a free whitening kit.
He temporarily dropped the offer to $58 during a slower period while adding hygienists and opening new offices.
The logic was straightforward.
If he was not making money at $98, he was willing to test whether lowering the barrier would create more volume.
According to Andrew, the result was a lower cost per new patient and fuller hygiene schedules. One newly opened office collected $243,000 in its first month.
The lesson is not that every practice should charge $58.
The lesson is to understand what the first hygiene appointment is actually doing for your business.
Your New-Patient Number Is Not the Whole Story
A practice can add hundreds of new patients and still struggle to build a durable patient base. Andrew and Collin’s point is that retention changes the math. When patients continue returning for hygiene, every new patient adds to the active patient population instead of simply replacing someone who disappeared from the schedule.
Three Different Models Can Work
One of the most useful parts of this conversation is that there is no single hygiene model being presented.
Blake, Andrew, and Collin have different economics.
Blake: Fee-for-service and marketing-driven
Blake operates outside insurance networks and invests heavily in marketing to generate new patients.
His goal is to build a patient population that is less dependent on insurance to choose the practice.
Andrew: In-network and volume-driven
Andrew intentionally stayed in network across his general dentistry practices because he wanted to grow a group of startups quickly.
He has around 17 hygienists across nine of 12 practices, with many offices seeing around 150 new patients per month and some reaching 250.
Collin: In-network and demand-driven
Collin’s practices also operate in network, but his growth model is different.
Marketing has not been a sophisticated part of the business. His offices tend to generate significant demand simply by opening in communities with a lot of need.
His lowest goal is 150 new patients per month per office, with some offices reaching 200.
Three models.
Three different markets.
The takeaway is not to copy one of them.
It is to understand the economics of your market and build your hygiene system around them.
The Metric That Changes Everything: Reappointment Rate
Andrew admitted that early in his ownership journey, he paid too little attention to hygiene.
He watched doctor production.
He watched revenue.
He watched top-line numbers.
But he did not track hygiene reappointment.
When he finally started tracking it, his offices were sitting around 65% to 70%.
That sounds better than it is.
If 30% of your patients are not getting reappointed, you have created a massive hole that new-patient marketing has to fill.
Andrew described the effect as a snowball.
The practice needs more and more new patients just to replace the patients who are leaving the hygiene schedule.
That is why retention changes the economics of growth.
Watch what happened when they paid attention
Andrew’s organization moved from:
65%–70% → 75% → 80% → 85% → 90% → 95%+
The change came from giving hygiene more attention, setting goals, and eventually adding a chief hygiene officer who could own the department’s performance.
In Q2 2026, the organization exceeded 95% hygiene reappointment, with a goal of 98% for Q3.
The bigger point is what Andrew said next.
He considers hygiene reappointment one of the strongest predictors of future practice success and growth.
And Collin explained why.
New patients add to your active patient count only when you retain them.
If you constantly lose patients, new-patient acquisition becomes an endless treadmill.
“It’s not new patient count, it’s active patient count.”
Reappointment Is a Leading Growth Metric
Andrew’s organization moved from roughly 65% to more than 95% hygiene reappointment after giving the metric focused attention. The lesson is not that 95% is a universal target. The lesson is that a metric you consistently measure, discuss, and manage can become a lever for growth instead of a number buried in a report.
Stop Treating Hygiene KPIs Like a Report Card
Andrew’s practices do not simply track reappointment and hope it improves.
They created a management system around the numbers.
His chief hygiene officer:
- Runs regular hygiene meetings
- Holds one-on-one conversations
- Shares educational material
- Researches products
- Reports KPI performance
- Uses weekly and monthly scoreboards
The scoreboards create friendly competition between hygienists.
That matters because the number itself is not the point.
The number tells you where to look.
Track behaviors that lead to growth
Andrew’s organization uses several hygiene metrics, including:
- Reappointment rate
- Periodontal percentage
- Fluoride percentage
- Other hygiene production and performance measures
They also use those numbers to create additional bonus opportunities.
A hygienist who struggles to hit the 3.3x production threshold can still earn recognition and compensation for leading in specific KPIs.
That creates a broader definition of winning.
A hygienist does not have to win in exactly one way.
Build Compensation Around the Economics
Collin’s compensation model starts with a simple rule:
Pay competitively first.
He says candidates compare the base salary to what they can make at another practice.
The bonus package matters.
The benefits matter.
But the hourly rate is still a major part of the hiring decision.
His practice targets compensation at approximately the top end of the local market and then creates upside through incentives.
The production target is:
Base pay × 3.3 = production target
Once a hygienist averages that level over the month, they participate in the upside.
Collin’s model gives the hygienist 20% of production above the 3.3x threshold.
Andrew uses the same basic 3.3x framework for unlocking commission, while acknowledging that higher base pay makes the threshold harder to reach.
But Blake adds an important warning.
Make the bonus durable
A compensation plan can look great on paper and become a problem six months later.
Blake’s advice is to account for the entire compensation package.
That includes:
- Employer payroll taxes
- 401(k) matches
- Health insurance
- Stipends
- Benefits
- Bonus payments
If you calculate your model using only hourly wages and ignore the rest, your 3.3x economics can quietly become something much lower.
The goal is not to create the biggest bonus.
The goal is to create a compensation system that the practice can happily sustain.
Base Pay Gets Talent Through the Door
A sophisticated bonus plan does not replace competitive base compensation. Andrew and Collin both emphasized that candidates compare the hourly rate first. Build a competitive base, then use incentives to create upside for production, KPIs, and team performance.
If You Cannot Fill Hygiene, Capacity Is Not the Problem
This is where Collin takes the conversation one step further.
He argues that a startup should think carefully about capacity from day one.
Rent is fixed.
Utilities are fixed.
A large portion of your overhead is already committed once the doors open.
A hygienist is a variable expense.
If you can generate enough new patients, adding hygiene capacity can help produce the revenue needed to absorb those fixed costs.
Collin’s practice uses two hygienists from the beginning of its startups.
He said the practice needs approximately 80 to 90 new patients per month to drive fixed costs down enough to begin making the economics work.
His philosophy is blunt:
Either invest early and get profitable faster, or underinvest and carry the problem longer.
But there is an important condition.
You need a reliable way to generate new patients.
Hiring two hygienists with no patient demand does not solve anything.
Capacity should follow the math
Andrew has taken a slightly different approach in newer startups.
Rather than automatically opening with two hygienists, his recent locations have added more doctor capacity because doctor availability was becoming the constraint.
Two of his last three startups opened with approximately one and a half doctors, and newer startups moved from three days per week to four.
He says those have been their most successful startups.
That is the larger lesson:
Do not add capacity because someone told you what a startup “should” look like.
Add capacity where your demand actually exists.
Read: Expand Smarter: How to Add Operatories Without Killing Cash Flow
Give Hygienists More Ownership
Blake’s final point brings the entire system together.
He believes hygienists need autonomy.
They should not feel like they are simply performing cleanings and waiting for the doctor to tell them what to do.
They should feel trusted to have meaningful conversations with patients.
That means the doctor has to support them.
If a hygienist tells a patient they are concerned about something and wants the doctor to take a look, the doctor needs to reinforce that communication.
Blake believes this leadership support is one of the missing pieces in practices that struggle to get better hygiene outcomes.
“Giving your hygienists autonomy and making them feel like they’re mid-level providers.”
That does not mean asking hygienists to diagnose outside their role.
It means giving them enough ownership to communicate what they see, explain why they are concerned, and confidently involve the doctor.
That creates a better patient experience and a stronger team.
Give Hygienists Permission to Own the Conversation
Hygienists need to know their doctor supports them. If they identify a concern and appropriately bring it to the patient’s attention before involving the doctor, leadership should reinforce that behavior. Autonomy gives the hygienist a reason to take ownership instead of simply completing the appointment and moving on.
The Hygiene Growth System
Put everything together and the framework becomes pretty simple.
1. Create Demand
Decide how you are going to generate enough new patients to support your hygiene capacity.
That might mean:
- Marketing
- A new-patient offer
- Community demand
- Location strategy
- Referrals
2. Fill the Schedule
Make sure your hygiene capacity matches the demand you can actually generate.
Do not hire blindly.
Do not underhire because you are afraid of payroll.
Use the numbers.
3. Retain the Patients
Track hygiene reappointment.
This is where the active patient base compounds.
4. Measure the Department
Use a small number of meaningful KPIs.
Then review them consistently.
5. Reward the Right Behaviors
Use competitive base compensation plus incentives that reward production, retention, clinical behaviors, and team performance.
6. Give the Team Ownership
Hygienists need clear expectations, autonomy, leadership support, and a reason to care about the outcome.
That is how hygiene becomes a growth system instead of a staffing problem.
Key Takeaways
- Hygiene does not have to be your biggest profit center. It can be the gateway that brings valuable patients into the practice.
- New-patient volume is only half the equation. Active patient count is what compounds over time.
- Track hygiene reappointment. Andrew’s practices improved from roughly 65% to more than 95% after giving the metric focused attention.
- Build compensation around your market. Competitive base pay gets talented people through the door, while incentives create additional upside.
- The 3.3x framework can create a clear production target. Both Collin and Andrew described using it to structure incentive compensation.
- Account for total compensation. Benefits, taxes, retirement matches, and other costs change the real economics.
- Add capacity based on demand. Hygienist and doctor capacity should solve the actual constraint in your practice.
- Give hygienists autonomy. When doctors support their communication and judgment within their role, the team can create a stronger patient experience.
Conclusion
There is no single “right” hygiene model.
Blake’s fee-for-service practice, Andrew’s in-network multi-practice model, and Collin’s in-network community-based model prove that.
The common thread is the system behind the model.
They understand what hygiene is supposed to do for their business.
They measure whether patients come back.
They create capacity around actual demand.
They pay people competitively.
They build incentives around measurable outcomes.
And they give hygienists enough ownership to contribute to the growth of the practice.
If your hygiene department feels broken, start with the numbers.
How many new patients are you putting into hygiene?
What percentage are coming back?
How much capacity do you actually have?
What does each hygienist need to produce?
And are your incentives aligned with the behavior you want?
You may not need a completely different hygiene model.
You may simply need to pay more attention to the system you already have.
Listen to the Full Episode
Hear Dr. Blake Hamblin, Gary Bird, Andrew Vallo, and Dr. Collin Myrick compare three very different approaches to building a high-performing hygiene department, from compensation and KPIs to new-patient acquisition, reappointment, and startup capacity.
Listen: OON vs FFS: Structuring Your Hygiene Department