If your hygiene compensation model only answers one question, “What is the hourly rate?” you are probably missing the bigger opportunity.
Dr. Blake Hamblin used to pay his hygienists strictly hourly. It worked, but he wanted something different. He wanted hygienists to own their outcomes, have more autonomy, create more value for patients, and actually want to stay with the practice.
That led him to build a compensation model around several pieces: hourly pay, commission, benefits, productivity, flexibility, and clear expectations.
The goal is not simply to pay a hygienist more.
The goal is to create a model where the patient, hygienist, and practice all win.
As Gary put it, “When incentives are aligned, then everybody wins.”
Here is how that model works.
“I wanted our hygienists to own their outcomes.”
Stop Thinking About Hygiene Pay as an Hourly Number
Hourly pay is easy to understand.
It is also easy to get stuck on.
In Blake’s market, he described full-time hourly hygienists as generally falling around $48 to $53 per hour, with $60 being an outlier. His own hygienists start around $45 per hour, with commission on top.
That commission can push their effective compensation significantly higher.
The important distinction is that Blake is not simply paying for time.
He is paying for value created.
That includes things like:
- Keeping patient information and routine care up to date
- Helping patients understand what is happening in their mouths
- Using diagnostic tools appropriately
- Helping patients make better decisions about their health
- Supporting treatment acceptance
- Creating a better patient experience
- Producing enough value to support the compensation model
The philosophy is simple: give the hygienist a way to earn more by creating more value.
That is very different from simply increasing the hourly rate every time someone asks for a raise.
The compensation model should create ownership
Blake said he did not want hygienists to simply be “plaque pickers.”
He wanted them to function as mid-level providers who actively serve patients and take ownership of their responsibilities.
That distinction matters.
If you want someone to own outcomes, your compensation structure should give them some control over those outcomes.
Read: How to Handle Dental Team Raise Requests
Benefits Are Part of Compensation
There is another part of the equation that dental practice owners sometimes overlook: benefits.
Blake’s hygienists receive:
- Hourly pay
- Commission
- 401(k)
- Health insurance
- Other employee benefits
- Consistent hours
- A stable team
- Autonomy
He explained that benefits are not free. They are a cost of doing business.
But he also sees them as a cost of retention.
That is an important way to look at the math.
You are not simply asking:
“Can I afford health insurance and a 401(k)?”
You should also ask:
“What does it cost me when a great hygienist leaves?”
Gary described that replacement cost as potentially six to twelve months of pay once you account for lost revenue, recruiting, advertising, interviews, notice periods, training, and the disruption that happens while a new person learns the practice.
“The cost of replacement.”
That is the number that deserves more attention.
A practice owner might save money by avoiding benefits today, then lose far more through turnover tomorrow.
A Better Question Than “What’s the Hourly Rate?”
Your hygienist’s hourly rate is only the starting point. Look at the full package: commission, benefits, flexibility, autonomy, and the value created for the practice. Blake’s model gives hygienists a path to earn more when they produce more, instead of making the entire conversation about increasing the hourly rate.
The Real Cost of Losing a Hygienist
Think through what happens when a good hygienist gives notice.
The problem starts before their final day.
They may begin checking out mentally.
Patient relationships can suffer.
Other team members absorb the workload.
Your schedule becomes harder to fill.
Then recruiting begins.
You have to:
- Create or run job ads.
- Review candidates.
- Interview people.
- Wait for the right candidate to become available.
- Wait through their notice period.
- Train them on your systems.
- Help them learn your technology.
- Help them understand your patient experience.
- Give them time to become productive.
That is why compensation should not be evaluated only as a payroll percentage.
It needs to be evaluated against the cost of instability.
If your goal is growth, keeping a strong hygienist can be less expensive than constantly replacing one.
Turnover Has a Price Tag
Replacing a hygienist creates costs long before the new person becomes productive. Recruiting, interviews, notice periods, training, lost production, and pressure on the rest of the team all add up. If a small increase in benefits or flexibility keeps a great hygienist, the cheaper option may be the one that looks more expensive on paper.
Build the Bonus Around Production
The most specific part of Blake’s model is the bonus structure.
His basic calculation is:
Hygienist compensation × 3.3 = production target
Blake explained that the hygienist should produce roughly 3.3 times their compensation within the charge.
That becomes the break-even point.
Anything above that can participate in the bonus structure.
In his model, the hygienist receives 20% of the amount above that threshold.
For example, if a hygienist earns $45 per hour:
$45 × 3.3 = $148.50
That gives the practice a production target of approximately $148.50 per hour.
The exact calculation and timing of the bonus can be structured monthly, quarterly, or by pay period.
The important concept is that the hygienist can see the relationship between:
What I earn → What I produce → What I create for the practice
Make the bonus visible
Blake specifically separates the commission on the hygienist’s pay stub.
That matters psychologically.
The hygienist can see:
- Their hourly earnings
- Their commission
- The additional value they created
The goal is not to make people obsessed with money.
The goal is to reinforce productive behavior.
If a hygienist changes their communication, uses the microscope, helps patients understand a problem, or finds a better way to serve patients, the additional compensation becomes feedback that those behaviors created value.
“This is what you made hourly, but this is also the value you created with your commissions.”
Read: Why Your Current Bonus System Is Failing (And How to Fix It Fast)
Productivity Should Start With the Patient
There is an obvious concern with commission-based compensation:
What stops a hygienist from pushing unnecessary treatment?
Blake’s answer starts with ethics.
He said an ethical standard is non-negotiable in his practice.
That means compensation should never reward someone for recommending something that is not appropriate for the patient.
The better question is:
How can we help the hygienist communicate what is actually happening so the patient can make a better decision?
That is where technology and communication come in.
Show, don’t just tell
Blake talked about using a microscope to show patients what is happening instead of simply telling them they have a problem.
When patients can actually see what the hygienist is seeing, they may understand the need for additional care differently.
The same principle can apply to:
- X-rays
- Microscope images
- Laser bacterial reduction
- Fluoride
- Hydroxyapatite
- Other appropriate preventive or clinical recommendations
Blake said the microscope has helped his team get more acceptance with services such as laser bacterial reduction, fluoride, and hydroxyapatite.
That is not about turning the hygienist into a salesperson.
It is about making the patient’s problem visible.
Show, Don’t Just Tell
Patients respond differently when they can see what the hygienist sees. Microscopes, X-rays, and other appropriate visual tools can make a clinical concern easier to understand. The goal is not to push treatment. It is to help the patient understand what is happening so they can make a better decision.
Your Hygienist Should Set Up the Doctor
One of the most useful ideas in the conversation is the role of the hygienist in treatment communication.
Gary described what happens when the hygienist notices something, explains the concern to the patient, and then brings the doctor into the conversation.
The patient has already heard:
“I see something here, and I’m concerned about it. I’m going to have the doctor take a look.”
Then the doctor confirms what the hygienist has already introduced.
That creates continuity.
Blake described the hygienist’s role as sharing what they see and sharing concern without diagnosing.
This can be as simple as:
“These are the things I’m seeing, and I’m concerned about them. I’m going to have the doctor take a look.”
That gives the patient time to process the problem before the doctor arrives.
It also prevents the doctor from walking in cold and having to introduce every concern from scratch.
“Part of your job is to share what you see.”
Flexibility Can Be Worth More Than Another Dollar Per Hour
Compensation is not always about money.
Blake made this point strongly near the end of the conversation.
He encouraged practice owners to actually ask their employees:
“What would be a win for you?”
The answer might be more money.
It might also be:
- More freedom
- Better hours
- More vacation
- A schedule that works around children
- More control over when they work
Blake’s practice created two hygiene shifts:
- 7 a.m. to 2 p.m.
- 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.
Hygienists coordinate the shifts with each other, giving them more flexibility around school, children, and family responsibilities.
That flexibility can become a recruiting advantage.
And it does not require a massive practice.
Gary pointed out that a smaller practice could use multiple part-time hygienists to create coverage and flexibility instead of relying on one person for every hygiene hour.
Build redundancy before you need it
Blake originally arrived at this model because he was tired of being dependent on two hygienists.
If one got sick, quit, got married, had a child, or otherwise became unavailable, the practice suddenly had a problem.
His solution was to create additional hygiene capacity without simply adding unnecessary cost.
By adjusting the schedule and adding providers, the practice could create more appointments and more flexibility.
That is a powerful growth principle:
Do not wait until you desperately need a hygienist to start building hygiene capacity.
The Triple Win
The compensation model ultimately comes back to one question:
Does everyone win?
The patient should receive better care and clearer communication.
The hygienist should have a strong income, benefits, flexibility, and a reason to stay.
The practice should generate enough production and stability to support the model.
That is the standard Gary and Blake kept coming back to throughout the conversation.
“If we can have that triple win, then that’s all I look for.”
If your compensation system creates a winner and a loser, the model will eventually break.
If the patient loses, you have an ethical problem.
If the hygienist loses, you have a retention problem.
If the practice loses, you have a financial problem.
The goal is to design the rules so all three sides have a reason to make the system work.
Before You Change Your Compensation Model, Ask Your Team
One of Blake’s final warnings is worth paying attention to.
Do not hear this episode and immediately decide:
“I need to commission my hygienists.”
Or:
“I need to add a 401(k).”
Or:
“I need to copy Blake’s schedule.”
Start with a question.
Gary used an employee net promoter score to collect feedback from his team. The team told him that better benefits and a 401(k) mattered. He acted on that feedback, and retention improved.
Blake’s point was simple:
“What would be a win for you?”
That question might reveal that your team does not actually want the thing you assumed they wanted.
You may think the answer is another $5 per hour.
They may want Fridays off.
You may think they want a larger bonus.
They may want predictable hours.
You may think they want more money.
They may want more autonomy.
Ask before you build.
Ask Before You Assume
Before changing compensation, ask your team one simple question: “What would be a win for you?” The answer may be more money. It may also be flexibility, vacation, benefits, or control over their schedule. Build around what your people actually value instead of assuming everyone is motivated the same way.
Key Takeaways
- Hourly pay is only one part of compensation. Benefits, flexibility, autonomy, and commission can all influence retention.
- Give hygienists ownership of outcomes. Compensation should reward value creation, not simply time spent in the office.
- Use the 3.3× framework. Blake’s model targets production at roughly 3.3 times hygienist compensation, with 20% of production above the threshold going back to the hygienist.
- Protect the patient first. Commission only works when ethical standards are clear and non-negotiable.
- Show patients what you see. Microscope images, X-rays, and clear communication can help patients understand their needs.
- Use the hygienist to tee up the doctor. Sharing concern before the doctor enters creates a smoother patient experience.
- Flexibility is a recruiting tool. Different shifts and part-time coverage can help practices attract and retain hygienists.
- Ask your team what they actually value. Do not assume more money is always the answer.
Conclusion
Dental hygienist compensation is not a single number.
It is a system.
Hourly pay gives you the foundation. Benefits and flexibility help create stability. Commission gives hygienists a way to participate in the value they create. Clear expectations protect the practice. Ethical communication protects the patient.
And when those pieces work together, compensation stops being a constant negotiation.
It becomes part of how the practice grows.
The bigger lesson from Blake’s model is not that every dentist should copy his exact numbers or schedule.
It is that you should build the rules of the game intentionally.
Find out what your team values.
Figure out what the hygienist needs to produce to support the position.
Give them a path to earn more by creating more value.
Then make sure the patient stays at the center of the entire system.
That is how you build a hygiene department that people want to stay in and a practice that can continue to grow.
Listen to the Full Episode
Want to hear Dr. Blake Hamblin and Gary Bird break down the actual compensation model, bonus structure, benefits, productivity expectations, and flexible scheduling behind Blake’s hygiene department?
Listen to the full My Dental Playbook episode and hear how the pieces fit together in a real dental practice.